31 Western Avenue Nantucket, MA 02554

  • Overview
  • Property Details
  • Location
$5,495,000
Asking Price
$4,500,000
Selling Price
Sold
Market Status
5 beds
Bedrooms
4 beds
Bathrooms
3,840 beds
Square Footage

Opportunity abounds to convert the stunning property into a private residence. Originally U.S. Life-Saving Station, then Star of the Sea Youth Hostel and now it awaits its new steward. Premium location on an oversized lot with unobstructed ocean views abutting Land Bank land and stairs to the beach across the street. Rare offering...

First Floor

Open room, separate office, kitchen, laundry and three bathrooms.

Second Floor

Open room with cathedral ceilings, access to the cupola, exterior access. Stunning water and conservation land views.

  • Selling Date 11/18/2025
  • Listed Date 11/21/2024
  • Days on Market 362
  • % To Listing Price 82
  • Total Rooms 9
  • Total Beds 5
  • Full Baths 4
  • Lot Size 0.6786 acres
  • Year Built 1873
  • Second Dwelling Yes
  • Zoning R20
  • Views Ocean, Pasture
Listed on by J Pepper Frazier Co.
31 Western Avenue - Sales History
nantucket sun icon

Location

What we like about Surfside

With Surfside, Fishermans, and Nobadeer beaches all in the area, Surfside is an easy jaunt from Town and Mid Island. Featuring family-friendly food trucks, beach rentals, and surf lessons, Surfside has everything you need for the ultimate beach day!

Learn more

Recommended for you

3 beds
2.1 beds

31 Flintlock Road

$2,975,000

10 beds
6.0 beds

35 Shell Street

$18,875,000

4 beds
4.1 beds

11 Columbus Avenue

$4,595,000

5 beds
5.2 beds

86 Cliff Road

$5,950,000

3 beds
3.1 beds

318 Milestone Road

$4,950,000

9 Correia Lane

$2,400,000

6 beds
6.2 beds

15 North Water Street

$10,995,000

2 beds
2.0 beds

2B Forrest Avenue

$1,395,000

10 beds
7.2 beds

52 Monomoy Road

$34,500,000

3 beds
3.0 beds

12 1/2 Ipswich Street

$2,950,000

9 beds
7.3 beds

21 Quidnet Road

$9,495,000

12 beds
10.1 beds

1 Ocean Avenue

$22,750,000

5 beds
5.2 beds

2A Morgan Square

$8,800,000

3 beds
2.0 beds

54 Union Street

$1,895,000

4 beds
3.1 beds

44 Sankaty Road

$4,500,000

4 beds
4.1 beds

8 Sconset Avenue

$4,650,000

4 beds
2.1 beds

14 Flintlock Road

$2,549,000

6 beds
6.3 beds

14 Correia Lane

$13,995,000

6 beds
5.1 beds

10 Doc Ryder Drive

$4,295,000

6 beds
6.2 beds

12 Correia Lane

$9,995,000

54 & 56 Meadow View Drive

$6,495,000

 
1.1 beds

43 Appleton Road

$1,995,000

6 beds
5.1 beds

1 Chester Street

$7,750,000

 
0.1 beds
884 sf beds

6 Straight Wharf

$3,159,000

15C Correia Lane

$2,175,000

8 beds
10.1 beds

6 Union Street

$9,995,000

36 Easton Street

$28,500,000

4 beds
3.1 beds

19 Orange Street

$4,695,000

2 beds
1.0 beds
984 sf beds

26 North Cambridge Street

$5,750,000

4 beds
3.0 beds

22 Sheep Pond Road

$2,395,000

8 beds
9.0 beds

20 Main Street

$12,000,000

4 beds
3.2 beds

118 Eel Point Road

$6,395,000

Nautical flags of Nantucket

Questions? Let us reach out to you.

  • Message (Optional)

Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266

A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.