Nantucket Summer Rentals That Are Perfect for Pairs
05/12/2026
If you've spent time on Nantucket, you know the rhythm - early beach walks, bike rides into town, and long evenings spent outside. When you're traveling as a pair, the right rental makes these experiences even better. From compact cottages to thoughtfully designed small homes, these Nantucket summer rentals are perfectly sized for two, offering comfort, privacy, and a home base for days that are easy to enjoy.
25 Broadway Cottage
Welcome to the Hope Chest's charming one-bedroom, one-bath retreat. This cozy space features a warm living room with a wood-burning fireplace, and puts you right in the heart of Sconset's magic, with ocean breezes, village charm, and easy walkability. Enjoy breakfast at Claudette's, stroll to the beach, explore the Bluff Walk, or grab ice cream from the Sconset Market - all just steps from your door. A rare multi-unit layout for privacy and togetherness allows flexible rental options: 3BR, 1BR, or 4BR whole property.
The first floor includes a welcoming living room with a frame TV, built-in bookcases, a fully equipped kitchen with new appliances, and a powder room. Upstairs, a serene queen bedroom suite offers water views, a TV, and a workspace. The lower level features a washer and dryer, a cozy seating area with flat-screen TV, and a Murphy bed for additional guests.
For more information on 25 Broadway Cottage, click here.
14 Old North Wharf
Lydia Cottage is a charming summer rental located on historic Old North Wharf, right in the heart of downtown. With a lovely yard for waterside lounging, it offers a peaceful setting just steps from town. The property includes a boat slip suitable for motorboats up to 32 feet and a dedicated parking space. The lawn, boat slip, and laundry area are shared with the neighboring cottage, adding to the relaxed, communal feel.
Inside, the first floor features a studio-style layout with a combined living and dining area overlooking the Easy Street boat basin. The space also includes a kitchen and full bath, making it a comfortable and convenient retreat by the water.
For more information on 14 Old North Wharf, click here.
46 Nonantum Rear Cottage
This cute one-bedroom apartment sits above a garage in the desirable Surfside area, offering water views and an easy walk to the beach. It's a cozy, private retreat ideal for a couple or solo traveler looking to enjoy the relaxed coastal setting.
Accessed via an interior staircase, the second floor features an open-concept kitchen, living, and dining area with French doors leading to a small deck overlooking the manicured lawn. The bedroom includes a queen bed and an ensuite bathroom with shower. A shared driveway provides space for one tenant vehicle.
For more information on 46 Nonantum Rear Cottage, click here.
14 Still Dock #4
This small one-bedroom apartment is ideally located just a short walk from Main Street and a variety of restaurants, offering a convenient and comfortable stay for one or two guests. With a deck, grill, and on-street parking, it's well-suited for enjoying relaxing island living, all within 0.75 miles of the beach.
The first floor features an open layout with a living and dining area, kitchen, half bath, and access to the deck. Upstairs, the second floor includes a master bedroom, full bath, and a cozy sitting area overlooking the harbor - perfect for unwinding after a day out.
For more information on 14 Still Dock #4, click here.
0 Charter Street
This charming one-bedroom cottage is located in town, just a short distance from the center, making it easy to enjoy many shops and restaurants. The cottage features a private patio off the back - shared in location with the main house but reserved for cottage guests, offering a cozy outdoor space to relax. Please note there is no off-street parking.
Inside, the first floor offers an open kitchen, living, and dining area with a bright cathedral ceiling. The queen bedroom also has access to the patio, and a full bedroom with a shower completes the layout, creating a comfortable and inviting retreat.
For more information on 0 Charter Street, click here.
3 Swain Street
This adorable two-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage in Brant Point is perfect for a couple or small family, offering a prime location that's just a short walk to Town, Jetties Beach, and Children's Beach. The home features central A/C, a washer and dryer, a deck and a yard, and an outdoor shower.
The first floor includes a cozy living area, open kitchen, a queen bedroom, and a second bedroom with two twin beds that share a hall bathroom. A charming loft with additional twin beds is accessed by a ship's ladder from the living room, providing extra sleeping space.
For more information on 3 Swain Street, click here.
15 Meader Street Unit A
This quintessential Nantucket cottage offers a beautifully designed retreat just steps from the beach and a short stroll to Main Street, with distant harbor views enhancing its charm. Built in 2016 and professionally decorated, the home features high-end finishes throughout, including shiplap walls, a gourmet kitchen, central A/C, Sonos sound system, and thoughtfully provided amenities like linens, toiletries, and beach gear. The outdoor space includes a gas grill, dining patio, and landscaped yard, perfect for relaxing after a day by the water.
Inside, the first floor features an open-concept kitchen, dining, and living area with stainless steel appliances, countertop seating, and a comfortable lounge with a flat-screen TV. Two bedrooms - one with a king bed and one with a queen - share a stylish hall bath with a glass-enclosed shower, offering a a cozy yet upscale stay.
For more information on 15 Meader Street Unit A, click here.
Renting a Home with Great Point Properties
Renting a home with Great Point Properties ensures a seamless and stress-free Nantucket experience from start to finish. With a wide selection of rental properties, Great Point Properties combines local expertise with personalized service, helping you find the perfect home for your group’s needs and lifestyle. From detailed property insights to responsive support throughout your stay, renting with Great Point Properties means peace of mind, exceptional comfort, and access to the island’s most desirable homes - all backed by a team that knows Nantucket inside and out.
For a complete list of all Nantucket rentals, click here.