134C Main Street Nantucket, MA 02554

  • Overview
  • Property Details
  • Location
$4,750,000
Asking Price
$4,700,000
Selling Price
Sold
Market Status
4 beds
Bedrooms
4 beds
Bathrooms
2,158 beds
Square Footage

This hidden gem was built in 1915 and housed Cady's Bakery, one of the first bakeries on Nantucket. The property is tucked off Main Street down a shell way, offering an unexpectedly private and quiet location, yet close to downtown shops and restaurants. The house is larger than expected offering an open floor plan with cathedral ceilings, stone gas fire place, and 4 bedrooms (2 with vaulted ceilings), and 4 bathroom (3 bedrooms are ensuite). Many details of the building were preserved including exposed beams and a sliding barn door. New elements include central AC, a gas fireplace, a covered porch, a finished lower level, and multiple stone patio areas outside for eating and lounging. Additional updates include a new cedar roof, copper gutters, exterior lighting, a gas line for the grill, a shed, and a foot bath/ dog wash. The property has a spacious covered porch and 3 patios, one is located in the front yard offering a sunny spot for early morning light, another in the side yard providing a perfect spot to enjoy the afternoon sun and a third patio is located off the living room for alfresco dining. The patios are connected by a fenced in yard. The current owner converted the property from a condo to a fee-simple ownership and installed dedicated utilities.

First Floor

Enter into an open cathedral-ceilinged living, dining, and gourmet kitchen area with windows on three sides and multiple doors to the back patio for alfresco dining or lounging. The hallway off the living room leads to two bedrooms. Each bedroom has French doors to the covered porch overlooking the yard and seating areas. The primary bedroom has an ensuite bath with tiled shower, the guest bedroom has ensuite access to a full hall bath which also serves as the powder room and a ladder to the loft.

Second Floor

An open loft offers storage or overflow sleeping spaces.

  • Selling Date 12/22/2025
  • Listed Date 12/22/2025
  • Days on Market 0
  • % To Listing Price 99
  • Total Rooms 12
  • Total Beds 4
  • Full Baths 4
  • Lot Size 0.105 acres
  • Year Built 2005
  • Zoning ROH
Listed on by Lee Real Estate
134C Main Street - Sales History
nantucket sun icon

Location

What we like about South Of Town

Moments to Town, yet centrally located among conservation land and bike paths.

Learn more

Recommended for you

65B Surfside Road

$849,000

6 beds
5.1 beds

10 Milk Street

$5,495,000

8 beds
6.2 beds

33 Pocomo Road

$17,995,000

4 beds
3.1 beds

44 Sankaty Road

$4,500,000

12A Greglen Avenue

$1,795,000

6 beds
4.2 beds

12 & 13 Shimmo Pond Road

$5,495,000

6 beds
3.0 beds

51 North Liberty Street

$2,595,000

5 beds
5.2 beds

36 West Chester Street

$7,795,000

4 beds
4.0 beds

25C Pine Street

$5,195,000

5 Gray Avenue, Lot 178

$1,750,000

5 Gray Avenue, Lot 177

$1,495,000

 
0.4 beds

17 Old South Road

$4,250,000

20 Nancy Ann Lane

$1,599,000

4 beds
4.0 beds

50 Lovers Lane

$4,895,000

3 beds
2.0 beds

4 Berkley Street

$2,099,000

4 beds
4.1 beds

40 Low Beach Road

$10,900,000

27 Fairgrounds Road

$7,995,000

 
3.2 beds

27 Fairgrounds Road

$7,995,000

5 beds
2.0 beds

8 Macy Road

$1,995,000

45 Easton Street

$7,995,000

10 beds
9.3 beds

24 Flintlock Road

$10,495,000

6 beds
4.1 beds

22 Vestal Street

$5,490,000

6 beds
6.0 beds

20 Pine Grove Road

$2,700,000

2 beds
2.0 beds

2A Forrest Avenue

$1,395,000

Nautical flags of Nantucket

Questions? Let us reach out to you.

  • Message (Optional)

Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266

A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.