12 Appleton Road Nantucket, MA 02554

  • Overview
  • Property Details
  • Location
$2,575,000
Asking Price
$2,500,000
Selling Price
Sold
Market Status
5 beds
Bedrooms
3 beds
Bathrooms
2,475 beds
Square Footage

Fully renovated and impeccably finished, this turn-key 5-bedroom, 3-bath home offers a complete top-to-bottom transformation with all-new systems, finishes, and fixtures throughout. Located in R5 zoning, the property allows for 40% ground cover, offering up to 5,440 square feet of buildout and substantial future expansion potential. Light-filled and refined, the interiors feature multiple living areas designed for both comfortable daily living and effortless entertaining. A separately accessed lower-level 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment—complete with custom built-ins, a kitchenette, and its own laundry—provides exceptional flexibility for guests, extended family, or income-producing use. The exterior has also been thoughtfully improved with all-new decking, and the home is privately sited on an oversized, secluded lot with ample outdoor space.

First Floor

From the parking area with ample space for several vehicles, step onto the inviting covered front porch. The first floor opens to a bright and welcoming living and dining area with an easy, open flow. The eat-in kitchen is thoughtfully designed with a dedicated dining area, pantry, and direct access to the rear deck - ideal for indoor-outdoor living. A first-floor bedroom and full bathroom provide flexibility and convenience.

Second Floor

The second floor opens to a bright, sun-filled living area, generously scaled and easily adaptable as an additional bedroom if desired. This level also includes two well-proportioned bedrooms, each with large closets, and a full bathroom.

  • Selling Date 10/19/2026
  • Listed Date 6/23/2026
  • Days on Market 118
  • % To Listing Price 97
  • Total Rooms 10
  • Total Beds 5
  • Full Baths 3
  • Lot Size 0.36 acres
  • Year Built 2006
  • Year Renovated 2025
  • Second Dwelling Yes
  • Zoning R5
Listed on by Maury People Sotheby's International Realty
12 Appleton Road - Sales History
  • Selling date: 9/30/2002
    Selling price: $200,000
  • Selling date: 11/16/2022
    Selling price: $1,400,000
nantucket sun icon

Location

What we like about Mid-island

Mid-Island is the heart of Nantucket, featuring many conveniences for locals and visitors alike. Home to many grocery stores, pharmacies, and restaurants, Mid-Island has all your island necessities.

Learn more

Recommended for you

3 beds
3.2 beds

38A Lovers Lane

$5,998,000

10 beds
10.2 beds

5 Capaum Pond Road

$17,950,000

6 beds
6.2 beds

3 Back Street

$7,745,000

5 beds
4.1 beds

4 Flintlock Road

$3,775,000

8 beds
6.2 beds

17 Ipswich Street

$7,195,000

8 beds
7.4 beds

119 Eel Point Road

$36,500,000

5 beds
4.1 beds

65A Surfside Road

$2,950,000

6 beds
6.1 beds

84 Cliff Road

$14,500,000

 
0.2 beds
816 sf beds

1 Hooper Farm Road

$2,500,000

2 beds
2.0 beds

17 New Street

$2,975,000

 
0.1 beds
801 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,100,000

 
0.1 beds
986 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,200,000

 
0.1 beds
986 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,200,000

 
0.1 beds
801 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,100,000

 
0.1 beds
801 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,100,000

 
0.1 beds
801 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,100,000

 
0.1 beds
801 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,100,000

 
0.1 beds
801 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,100,000

 
0.1 beds
986 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,200,000

 
0.1 beds
984 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,200,000

 
0.1 beds
801 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,100,000

 
0.1 beds
801 sf beds

2,4,6,8 Spearhead and 9 Arrowhead Road

$1,100,000

5 beds
5.1 beds

8 Hedge Row

$7,995,000

4 beds
4.0 beds

19 Beach Grass Road

$2,295,000

5 beds
3.0 beds

171 Orange Street

$9,495,000

5 beds
4.1 beds

6 White Elephant Way

$10,350,000

6 beds
6.2 beds

4 Wood Hollow Road

$7,995,000

9 beds
9.2 beds

7 Brewster Road

$18,750,000

10 Sheep Commons Lane

$8,995,000

 

44 Prospect Street (Lot A)

$2,100,000

3 beds
3.0 beds

40 Sherburne Commons Lane

$2,395,000

4 beds
3.0 beds

99 Surfside Road

$3,795,000

4 beds
4.0 beds

10 Farmview Drive

$4,595,000

8 beds
4.6 beds

21 Amelia Drive

$6,875,000

3 Wigwam Road

$3,595,000

3 beds
1.0 beds
708 sf beds

1 Sankaty Road

$2,695,000

3 beds
3.1 beds

11 West Creek Road & 41.5 Nobadeer Farm Road

$12,495,000

5 beds
4.0 beds

21A Pine Grove

$2,250,000

31 Millbrook Road

$2,995,000

6 beds
6.2 beds

9 Correia Lane

$9,950,000

8 beds
8.2 beds

59 Polpis Road

$11,950,000

5 beds
5.1 beds

4 White Elephant Way

$9,450,000

3 beds
3.0 beds

19 Wanoma Way

$4,295,000

5 beds
5.1 beds

39A Milk Street

$4,600,000

4 beds
1.0 beds

193 Eel Point Road

$14,500,000

6 beds
6.2 beds

144 Madaket Road

$9,250,000

4 beds
3.1 beds

263 Polpis Road

$7,595,000

2 beds
2.0 beds
884 sf beds

2 Forrest Avenue Condominium

$2,395,000

4 Harbor View Way

$8,975,000

8 beds
8.2 beds

8 Sheep Pond Road

$7,495,000

Nautical flags of Nantucket

Questions? Let us reach out to you.

  • Message (Optional)

Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266

A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.