Menu

Nantucket MLS

6 Gay Street Nantucket, MA 02554

Overview
Property Details
Location

$3,500,000

Asking Price

$3,202,500

Selling Price

Sold

Market Status

4

beds

Bedrooms

3

beds

Bathrooms

2,572

beds

Square Footage

Tucked away on a quiet side street just moments from the heart of downtown Nantucket, this well maintained four-bedroom, three-bath Federal style home blends historic charm with modern comfort. Sunlight pours through numerous windows and glass doors, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor connection to the deck and stone patio. Six fireplaces, original wood floors, and preserved architectural details speak to its rich history, while central air conditioning and off-street parking provide contemporary convenience. A true gem in an unbeatable location.

First Floor

Front entry with gracious staircase to second floor. Coat closet. To the left of the front entry is a living room with fireplace, closet, bookcase and built-in cabinet for the TV. To the right of the front entry is a second living room with fireplace, built-in book cases, closet and glass doors accessing the exterior deck and patio. The front hallway leads to the formal dining room with fireplace and glass doors to the deck and patio. The kitchen is beyond the dining room with a comfortable breakfast bar. A side door in the kitchen also leads to the deck and patio. Off the kitchen is a small bedroom with a full bath with tub/shower in the hallway. The laundry is in a hall closet. Rear staircase. There is a small enclosed finished porch which accesses the rear yard.

Second Floor

Second floor landing with charming sitting area. Bedroom/sitting room with fireplace and closet. Primary bedroom with fireplace, 2 closets and full bath with shower. The rear area of the second floor contains a bedroom with fireplace, hallway to full bath with tub/shower and an eat-in kitchen. Staircase to first floor and attic.

Third Floor

Unfinished attic.

Selling Date 12/17/2025
Listed Date 3/18/2025
Days on Market 274
% To Listing Price 92

Total Rooms 10
Total Beds 4
Full Baths 3

Lot Size 0.0866 acres
Year Built 1800
Year Renovated 2010
Second Dwelling Yes

Zoning ROH

Listed on March 18, 2025 by William Raveis Nantucket

Location

What we like about South Of Town

Moments to Town, yet centrally located among conservation land and bike paths.

Recommended for you

9 Pleasant Street - Town, Nantucket MA

5

4.1

9 Pleasant Street

$10,995,000

21 Vesper Lane - South of Town, Nantucket MA

4

3.0

21 Vesper Lane

$2,750,000

6 Arkansas Avenue - Madaket, Nantucket MA

3

3.1

6 Arkansas Avenue

$2,295,000

20 Lyons Lane - Tom Nevers, Nantucket MA

3

1.1

20 Lyons Lane

$2,490,000

47 Morey Lane - Sconset, Nantucket MA

6

3.0

47 Morey Lane

$4,750,000

27 Longwood Drive - Tom Nevers, Nantucket MA

5

4.1

27 Longwood Drive

$4,000,000

15 Hallowell Lane - Cliff, Nantucket MA

4

6.1

15 Hallowell Lane

$22,000,000

20 Evergreen Way - Surfside, Nantucket MA

4

4.0

20 Evergreen Way

$3,095,000

34 Pine Street - Town, Nantucket MA

3

4.0

34 Pine Street

$2,695,000

9 Millbrook Road (Portion) - Hummock Pond, Nantucket MA

9 Millbrook Road (Portion)

$3,300,000

10 Pilgrim Road - Cliff, Nantucket MA

4

4.1

10 Pilgrim Road

$4,475,000

1 South Mill Street - Town, Nantucket MA

1

1.0

645 sf

1 South Mill Street

$2,275,000

10 Beach Grass Road - Sandpiper, Nantucket MA

4

5.1

10 Beach Grass Road

$2,825,000

17B Old South Road - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

2

2.1

17B Old South Road

$975,000

31 Flintlock Road - Tom Nevers, Nantucket MA

3

2.1

31 Flintlock Road

$2,695,000

247 Polpis Road - Polpis, Nantucket MA

7

8.2

247 Polpis Road

$9,995,000

8 Sea Street - Town, Nantucket MA

2

2.1

8 Sea Street

$4,500,000

26 Easy Street - Town, Nantucket MA

1

1.1

26 Easy Street

$4,500,000

45 Sheep Pond Road - Madaket, Nantucket MA

4

3.1

45 Sheep Pond Road

$2,995,000

83 Baxter Road - Sconset, Nantucket MA

4

3.0

83 Baxter Road

$1,895,000

21 Kittiwake Lane - Naushop, Nantucket MA

3

2.1

21 Kittiwake Lane

$2,350,000

15 Point Judith Lane - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

15 Point Judith Lane

$1,825,000

48 Madequecham Valley Road - Madequecham, Nantucket MA

2

1.1

48 Madequecham Valley Road

$2,995,000

106 Old South Road - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

8

4.2

106 Old South Road

$2,495,000

321 Madaket Road - Madaket, Nantucket MA

3

2.1

321 Madaket Road

$3,495,000

44 Madequecham Valley Road - Madequecham, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

44 Madequecham Valley Road

$4,995,000

38 Hooper Farm Road - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

5

4.1

38 Hooper Farm Road

$2,495,000

7 Moors End Lane - Polpis, Nantucket MA

7

7.2

7 Moors End Lane

$9,995,000

74 Madaket Road - West of Town, Nantucket MA

West of Town

74 Madaket Road

$3,100,000

3 Monohansett Road - Surfside, Nantucket MA

3

4.1

3 Monohansett Road

$4,350,000

25 North Pasture Lane - Shawkemo, Nantucket MA

4

4.4

25 North Pasture Lane

$12,995,000

9 Nobadeer Way - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

9 Nobadeer Way

$2,250,000

1 Airport Road - Airport, Nantucket MA

1 Airport Road

$2,295,000

1 Airport Road - Airport, Nantucket MA

1 Airport Road

$1,995,000

121 Surfside Road - Surfside, Nantucket MA

4

6.1

121 Surfside Road

$4,850,000

14 & 16 Sheep Pond Road - Madaket, Nantucket MA

6

4.2

14 & 16 Sheep Pond Road

$1,800,000

26 Milk Street (Lot 1) - Town, Nantucket MA

5

3.1

26 Milk Street (Lot 1)

$3,800,000

26R Milk Street (Lot 2) - Town, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

26R Milk Street (Lot 2)

$3,050,000

15 Skyline Drive - Surfside, Nantucket MA

5

4.2

15 Skyline Drive

$4,495,000

26 Milk Street - Town, Nantucket MA

8

5.1

26 Milk Street

$6,650,000

15 North Water Street & 10 Sea Street - Town, Nantucket MA

6

6.2

15 North Water Street & 10 Sea Street

$13,500,000

25 Nobadeer Avenue Lot 2 - Surfside, Nantucket MA

25 Nobadeer Avenue Lot 2

$3,500,000

6 Honeysuckle Drive - Sandpiper, Nantucket MA

6 Honeysuckle Drive

$1,350,000

17 Pond View Drive - Miacomet, Nantucket MA

3

2.1

17 Pond View Drive

$4,499,000

15 Gingy Lane - Town, Nantucket MA

10

9.4

15 Gingy Lane

$8,650,000

2 Goldenrod Court - Sandpiper, Nantucket MA

4

4.0

2 Goldenrod Court

$2,499,900

6 Eagle Lane - Town, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

6 Eagle Lane

$2,495,000

85R Orange Street - Town, Nantucket MA

4

3.1

85R Orange Street

$3,395,000

25 Pond View Drive - Miacomet, Nantucket MA

6

5.0

25 Pond View Drive

$5,300,000

11 Woodland Drive - Surfside, Nantucket MA

11 Woodland Drive

$1,650,000

105 Low Beach Road - Sconset, Nantucket MA

5

5.0

105 Low Beach Road

$12,995,000

18 Mill Street - Town, Nantucket MA

6

5.1

18 Mill Street

$7,195,000

52 Pleasant Street - Town, Nantucket MA

4

2.1

52 Pleasant Street

$2,295,000

33 Pine Street - Town, Nantucket MA

5

4.1

33 Pine Street

$3,700,000

75 Fairgrounds Road - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

6

5.1

75 Fairgrounds Road

$5,295,000

15 Nancy Ann Lane - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

15 Nancy Ann Lane

$3,250,000

10 Sea Street - Town, Nantucket MA

10 Sea Street

$2,950,000

6 Bittersweet Lane - South of Town, Nantucket MA

6 Bittersweet Lane

$1,475,000

45 Starbuck Road - Madaket, Nantucket MA

4

4.1

45 Starbuck Road

$7,995,000

26 Easy Street - Town, Nantucket MA

26 Easy Street

$2,850,000

View All Listings

Nautical flags of Nantucket

Questions? Let us reach out to you.

Message (Optional)
Message

Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266

A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.