24 Milk Street Nantucket, MA 02554

Town

Overview
Property Details
Location

Contact Agent

$3,150,000

Asking Price

$2,985,000

Selling Price

Sold

Market Status

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

1,070

Square Footage

24 Milk Street Nantucket is a rare turnkey property in the heart of Nantucket Town, offering historic charm, modern luxury, and exceptional expansion potential in the highly sought-after Residential Old Historic district. This newly renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath Nantucket cottage sits on a conforming lot with private off-street parking for two vehicles and potential for a third space — a valuable amenity in Town. Thoughtfully restored and fully furnished by Melanie Gowen Design, 24 Milk Street seamlessly blends timeless Nantucket character with today’s modern conveniences. The home is ready for immediate occupancy, making it ideal as a year-round residence, summer getaway, or high-performing Nantucket rental investment property. Outdoor living is equally inviting, with beautifully landscaped gardens, multiple private patio areas, and ample space for entertaining or relaxing after a day at the beach. Adding to its appeal, the sale includes proposed architectural plans by renowned Nantucket architect Ben Normand to expand the existing cottage into a stunning 4-bedroom plus bunkroom, 3.5-bath luxury home. Buyers also have the flexibility to utilize remaining ground cover for a potential second structure. Located moments from Nantucket’s historic downtown, shops, restaurants, and beaches, 24 Milk Street Nantucket presents a unique opportunity to own a move-in-ready historic home with future expansion possibilities in one of the island’s most desirable neighborhoods.

First Floor

The main living room filled with many windows enjoys views onto the gardens from all three sides. Open concept plan with a dining area features built-in bookcases, a large cozy fireplace, original beams, and a flat screen smart television. Dining area seats six, bathed in sunlight along the rear patio facing windows. A brand new galley kitchen provides with top of the line appliances is compact and efficient for cooking and entertaining, with appliances hidden behind custom cabinetry panels. A farm sink and butler's pantry-like shelving provides neat storage. Honed Carrara marble countertops, beautiful slate floor, unlacquered brass Rohl plumbing fixtures, and dimmable architectural recessed lighting. At the rear of the house is a spacious primary suite with en suite bathroom that has a large walk-in shower. Towards the front of the house is a second full bath and laundry area concealed under the stairs. Newly installed 3-zone air conditioning system is a combination of central ducted and mini split ductless.

Second Floor

Two bedrooms share a small landing area. The smaller bedroom has a built-in twin bed with twin trundle pullout. The larger bedroom functions as a king suite with a built-in window seat, daybed area, closet, and views overlooking the garden and grounds.